Table 10 Outcome of the first editorial decision (OTR rate) as a function of the group of the corresponding author’s institution and the peer review model
From: Uptake and outcome of manuscripts in Nature journals by review model and author characteristics
Outcome | Institution group 1 | Institution group 2 | Institution group 3 | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
DBPR | SBPR | DBPR | SBPR | DBPR | SBPR | |
Rejected outright | 241 (85.8%) | 4300 (62.4%) | 1696 (86.8%) | 17,253 (73.8%) | 4487 (91.8%) | 27,559 (81.3%) |
Out to review | 40 (14.2%) | 2586 (37.6%) | 259 (13.2%) | 6137 (26.2%) | 399 (8.2%) | 6327 (18.7%) |