Table 8 Outcome of the first editorial decision (OTR rate) as a function of corresponding author’s gender and peer review model
From: Uptake and outcome of manuscripts in Nature journals by review model and author characteristics
Outcome | Female corresponding authors | Male corresponding authors | NA value for gender of corresponding authors | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
DBPR | SBPR | DBPR | SBPR | DBPR | SBPR | |
Rejected outright | 1549 (89.6%) | 11,944 (76.3%) | 7835 (91.7%) | 57,211 (76.0%) | 4109 (92.2%) | 18,579 (81.5%) |
Out to review | 180 (10.4%) | 3706 (23.7%) | 713 (8.3%) | 18,071 (24.0%) | 349 (7.8%) | 4208 (18.5%) |