Skip to main content

Advertisement

Table 6 True intervention ARRIVE subitem compliance; %, percentage of compliant manuscripts; CI, confidence interval; n, number of compliant manuscripts; N, total number of applicable manuscripts

From: A randomised controlled trial of an Intervention to Improve Compliance with the ARRIVE guidelines (IICARus)

  Control Intervention
ARRIVE subitem % 95% CIs n N % 95% CIs n N
1 41.76 36.5–47.2 142 340 45.85 40.1–51.7 138 301
2 71.76 66.6–76.4 244 340 66.45 60.8–71.7 200 301
3a 100.00 98.6–100 340 340 100.00 98.4–100 301 301
3b 34.12 29.1–39.5 116 340 35.88 30.5–41.6 108 301
4 91.18 87.5–93.9 310 340 93.02 89.4–95.5 280 301
5 69.41 64.2–74.2 236 340 72.43 66.9–77.3 218 301
6a 70.00 64.8–74.8 238 340 75.42 70.1–80.1 227 301
6b 8.33 5.7–12 28 336 9.49 6.5–13.6 28 295
6c 90.00 86.2–92.9 306 340 88.70 84.4–91.9 267 301
7a 16.76 13–21.3 57 340 16.94 13–21.8 51 301
7b 44.37 38.7–50.2 134 302 52.21 46.1–58.3 142 272
7c 8.64 5.8–12.5 26 301 14.07 10.3–18.9 38 270
7d 3.63 1.9–6.6 11 303 4.00 2.1–7.2 11 275
8a 4.71 2.8–7.7 16 340 7.97 5.3–11.8 24 301
8b 57.06 51.6–62.4 194 340 62.46 56.7–67.9 188 301
9a 0.30 0–1.9 1 337 3.03 1.5–5.9 9 297
9b 52.06 46.6–57.5 177 340 74.75 69.4–79.5 225 301
9c 14.71 11.2–19 50 340 21.26 16.9–26.4 64 301
10a 37.35 32.2–42.8 127 340 43.19 37.6–49 130 301
10b 3.53 1.9–6.2 12 340 7.64 5–11.4 23 301
10c 18.15 14.3–22.8 61 336 15.12 11.3–19.9 44 291
11a 4.82 2.8–8 15 311 7.53 4.8–11.4 21 279
11b 1.24 0.4–3.4 4 323 3.17 1.6–6.1 9 284
12 1.76 0.7–4 6 340 2.99 1.5–5.8 9 301
13a 87.50 83.4–90.7 294 336 89.90 85.8–93 267 297
13b 44.08 38.7–49.6 149 338 45.97 40.2–51.8 137 298
13c 10.06 7.2–13.9 34 338 12.75 9.3–17.2 38 298
14 0.29 0–1.9 1 340 0.00 0–1.6 0 301
15a 37.35 32.2–42.8 127 340 36.54 31.1–42.3 110 301
15b 12.65 9.4–16.8 43 340 14.95 11.2–19.6 45 301
16 78.55 73.7–82.8 260 331 81.03 75.9–85.3 235 290
17a 16.47 12.8–20.9 56 340 21.93 17.5–27.1 66 301
17b 1.18 0.4–3.2 4 340 1.66 0.6–4.1 5 301
18a 100.00 98.6–100 340 340 99.34 97.4–99.9 299 301
18b 26.47 21.9–31.6 90 340 27.57 22.7–33.1 83 301
18c 2.94 1.5–5.5 10 340 2.99 1.5–5.8 9 301
19 77.94 73.1–82.2 265 340 78.07 72.9–82.5 235 301
20 51.47 46–56.9 175 340 54.49 48.7–60.2 164 301