A randomised controlled trial of an Intervention to Improve Compliance with the ARRIVE guidelines (IICARus)

Hair, Kaitlyn; Macleod, Malcolm R.; Sena, Emily S.

doi:10.1186/s41073-019-0069-3

Table 6 True intervention ARRIVE subitem compliance; %, percentage of compliant manuscripts; CI, confidence interval; n, number of compliant manuscripts; N, total number of applicable manuscripts

From: A randomised controlled trial of an Intervention to Improve Compliance with the ARRIVE guidelines (IICARus)

	Control				Intervention
ARRIVE subitem	%	95% CIs	n	N	%	95% CIs	n	N
1	41.76	36.5–47.2	142	340	45.85	40.1–51.7	138	301
2	71.76	66.6–76.4	244	340	66.45	60.8–71.7	200	301
3a	100.00	98.6–100	340	340	100.00	98.4–100	301	301
3b	34.12	29.1–39.5	116	340	35.88	30.5–41.6	108	301
4	91.18	87.5–93.9	310	340	93.02	89.4–95.5	280	301
5	69.41	64.2–74.2	236	340	72.43	66.9–77.3	218	301
6a	70.00	64.8–74.8	238	340	75.42	70.1–80.1	227	301
6b	8.33	5.7–12	28	336	9.49	6.5–13.6	28	295
6c	90.00	86.2–92.9	306	340	88.70	84.4–91.9	267	301
7a	16.76	13–21.3	57	340	16.94	13–21.8	51	301
7b	44.37	38.7–50.2	134	302	52.21	46.1–58.3	142	272
7c	8.64	5.8–12.5	26	301	14.07	10.3–18.9	38	270
7d	3.63	1.9–6.6	11	303	4.00	2.1–7.2	11	275
8a	4.71	2.8–7.7	16	340	7.97	5.3–11.8	24	301
8b	57.06	51.6–62.4	194	340	62.46	56.7–67.9	188	301
9a	0.30	0–1.9	1	337	3.03	1.5–5.9	9	297
9b	52.06	46.6–57.5	177	340	74.75	69.4–79.5	225	301
9c	14.71	11.2–19	50	340	21.26	16.9–26.4	64	301
10a	37.35	32.2–42.8	127	340	43.19	37.6–49	130	301
10b	3.53	1.9–6.2	12	340	7.64	5–11.4	23	301
10c	18.15	14.3–22.8	61	336	15.12	11.3–19.9	44	291
11a	4.82	2.8–8	15	311	7.53	4.8–11.4	21	279
11b	1.24	0.4–3.4	4	323	3.17	1.6–6.1	9	284
12	1.76	0.7–4	6	340	2.99	1.5–5.8	9	301
13a	87.50	83.4–90.7	294	336	89.90	85.8–93	267	297
13b	44.08	38.7–49.6	149	338	45.97	40.2–51.8	137	298
13c	10.06	7.2–13.9	34	338	12.75	9.3–17.2	38	298
14	0.29	0–1.9	1	340	0.00	0–1.6	0	301
15a	37.35	32.2–42.8	127	340	36.54	31.1–42.3	110	301
15b	12.65	9.4–16.8	43	340	14.95	11.2–19.6	45	301
16	78.55	73.7–82.8	260	331	81.03	75.9–85.3	235	290
17a	16.47	12.8–20.9	56	340	21.93	17.5–27.1	66	301
17b	1.18	0.4–3.2	4	340	1.66	0.6–4.1	5	301
18a	100.00	98.6–100	340	340	99.34	97.4–99.9	299	301
18b	26.47	21.9–31.6	90	340	27.57	22.7–33.1	83	301
18c	2.94	1.5–5.5	10	340	2.99	1.5–5.8	9	301
19	77.94	73.1–82.2	265	340	78.07	72.9–82.5	235	301
20	51.47	46–56.9	175	340	54.49	48.7–60.2	164	301

Back to article page