Table 4 A suggested contributor list for journal decision making in scientific manuscript peer review. Note that contributors may also be listed anonymously
STAGE | Executive decision | Assisting in decision | Consulted for decision |
|---|---|---|---|
Screening | E.g., editor in chief or associate editor(s). | E.g., editor in chief or associate editor(s). | External or internal experts. |
External review | E.g., editor in chief or associate editor(s). | E.g., editor in chief or associate editor(s). | External or internal experts. |
Revisions | E.g., editor in chief or associate editor(s). | E.g., editor in chief or associate editor(s). | External or internal experts. |
Final decision | E.g., editor in chief or associate editor(s). | E.g., editor in chief or associate editor(s). | External or internal experts. |