Skip to main content

Advertisement

Table 2 Reviews completed by all enrolled participants

From: Mentored peer review of standardized manuscripts as a teaching tool for residents: a pilot randomized controlled multi-center study

Part A: specific manuscript reviews completed Total, n = 78 Non-mentored, n = 39 Mentored, n = 39  
 Manuscript 1: randomized controlled trial 64 (82%) 30 (47%) 34 (53%)  
 Manuscript 2: systematic review 49 (63%) 26 (53%) 23 (47%)  
 Manuscript 3: diagnostic accuracy study 35 (45%) 18 (51%) 17 (49%)  
 Manuscript 4a: observational study 29 (42%) 14 (48%) 15 (52%)  
 Manuscript 5: randomized controlled trial 44 (56%) 24 (55%) 20 (45%)  
Part B: total number of reviews completed Total (%) Non-mentored Mentored p value
 No reviews completed 14 (18.0) 9 (64%) 5 (36%) 0.238
 1 review 10 (12.8) 2 (20%) 8 (80%) 0.0421
 2 reviews 8 (10.3) 4 (50%) 4 (50%) 1
 3 reviews 10 (12.8) 5 (50%) 5 (50%) 1
 4 reviews 15 (19.2) 8 (53%) 7 (47%) 0.77
 5 reviews 21 (26.9) 11 (52%) 10 (48%) 0.799
  1. a9 students (5 non-mentored, 4 mentored) only received 4 manuscripts and did not complete manuscript 4
  2. Chi-squared with 1 degrees of freedom test