Skip to main content

Advertisement

Table 3 ARRIVE subitem compliance in mouse studies. %, percentage of compliant manuscripts; CI, confidence interval; n, number of compliant manuscripts; N, total number of applicable manuscripts; Adj p, adjusted p value; Cohen’s H, Cohen’s H effect size

From: A randomised controlled trial of an Intervention to Improve Compliance with the ARRIVE guidelines (IICARus)

  Control Intervention   
ARRIVE subitem % 95% CIs n N % 95% CIs n N Adj p Cohen’s H
1 37.44 31–44.4 79 211 37.50 30.7–44.8 72 192 > 0.99 0.00
2 68.25 61.4–74.4 144 211 60.42 53.1–67.3 116 192 > 0.99 − 0.16
3a 100.00 97.8–100 211 211 100.00 97.6–100 192 192 > 0.99 0.00
3b 30.33 24.3–37.1 64 211 29.69 23.4–36.8 57 192 > 0.99 − 0.01
4 89.10 83.9–92.8 188 211 92.19 87.2–95.4 177 192 > 0.99 0.11
5 67.77 61–73.9 143 211 71.88 64.9–78 138 192 > 0.99 0.09
6a 63.98 57.1–70.4 135 211 71.35 64.3–77.5 137 192 > 0.99 0.16
6b 5.24 2.8–9.4 11 210 7.89 4.6–12.9 15 190 > 0.99 0.11
6c 90.05 85–93.6 190 211 91.15 86–94.6 175 192 > 0.99 0.04
7a 17.54 12.8–23.5 37 211 17.71 12.7–24 34 192 > 0.99 0.00
7b 44.68 37.5–52.1 84 188 48.57 41–56.2 85 175 > 0.99 0.08
7c 6.91 3.9–11.8 13 188 9.83 6–15.5 17 173 > 0.99 0.11
7d 3.16 1.3–7.1 6 190 2.27 0.7–6.1 4 176 > 0.99 − 0.05
8a 4.74 2.4–8.8 10 211 6.25 3.4–10.9 12 192 > 0.99 0.07
8b 55.45 48.5–62.2 117 211 60.94 53.6–67.8 117 192 > 0.99 0.11
9a 0.47 0–3 1 211 2.08 0.7–5.6 4 192 > 0.99 0.15
9b 49.76 42.8–56.7 105 211 70.31 63.2–76.6 135 192 0.003 0.42
9c 15.17 10.7–20.9 32 211 23.96 18.2–30.7 46 192 > 0.99 0.22
10a 27.01 21.3–33.6 57 211 31.25 24.9–38.4 60 192 > 0.99 0.09
10b 2.84 1.2–6.4 6 211 5.73 3–10.3 11 192 > 0.99 0.14
10c 21.15 15.9–27.5 44 208 15.43 10.7–21.6 29 188 > 0.99 − 0.15
11a 4.12 1.9–8.3 8 194 5.00 2.5–9.6 9 180 > 0.99 0.04
11b 1.93 0.6–5.2 4 207 0.54 0–3.4 1 185 > 0.99 −0.13
12 0.00 0–2.2 0 211 3.65 1.6–7.7 7 192 0.40 0.38
13a 87.20 81.8–91.3 184 211 89.58 84.2–93.4 172 192 > 0.99 0.07
13b 46.92 40.1–53.9 99 211 42.71 35.7–50 82 192 > 0.99 − 0.08
13c 8.06 4.9–12.8 17 211 11.46 7.5–17 22 192 > 0.99 0.12
14 0.00 0–2.2 0 211 0.00 0–2.4 0 192 > 0.99 0.00
15a 36.02 29.6–42.9 76 211 36.46 29.7–43.7 70 192 > 0.99 0.01
15b 11.37 7.6–16.6 24 211 10.94 7.1–16.4 21 192 > 0.99 − 0.01
16 84.62 78.8–89.1 176 208 80.95 74.5–86.1 153 189 > 0.99 − 0.10
17a 15.64 11.2–21.4 33 211 23.44 17.8–30.2 45 192 > 0.99 0.20
17b 0.95 0.2–3.7 2 211 2.60 1–6.3 5 192 > 0.99 0.13
18a 100.00 97.8–100 211 211 98.96 95.9–99.8 190 192 > 0.99 − 0.20
18b 27.01 21.3–33.6 57 211 26.56 20.6–33.5 51 192 > 0.99 − 0.01
18c 3.32 1.5–7 7 211 3.13 1.3–7 6 192 > 0.99 − 0.01
19 82.46 76.5–87.2 174 211 81.77 75.4–86.8 157 192 > 0.99 − 0.02
20 51.18 44.2–58.1 108 211 56.25 48.9–63.3 108 192 > 0.99 0.10