Skip to main content

Advertisement

Table 4 ARRIVE subitem compliance in rat studies. %, percentage of compliant manuscripts; CI, confidence interval; n, number of compliant manuscripts; N, total number of applicable manuscripts; Adj p, adjusted p value; Cohen’s H, Cohen’s H effect size

From: A randomised controlled trial of an Intervention to Improve Compliance with the ARRIVE guidelines (IICARus)

  Control Intervention   
ARRIVE subitem % 95% CIs n N % 95% CIs n N Adj p Cohen’s H
1 47.27 33.9–61.1 26 55 59.09 46.3–70.8 39 66 > 0.99 0.24
2 83.64 70.7–91.8 46 55 81.82 70–89.9 54 66 > 0.99 − 0.05
3a 100.00 91.9–100 55 55 100.00 93.1–100 66 66 > 0.99 0.00
3b 20.00 10.9–33.4 11 55 34.85 23.8–47.7 23 66 > 0.99 0.34
4 96.36 86.4–99.4 53 55 96.97 88.5–99.5 64 66 > 0.99 0.03
5 83.64 70.7–91.8 46 55 80.30 68.3–88.7 53 66 > 0.99 − 0.09
6a 90.91 79.3–96.6 50 55 87.88 77–94.3 58 66 > 0.99 − 0.10
6b 24.53 14.2–38.6 13 53 21.54 12.7–33.8 14 65 > 0.99 − 0.07
6c 98.18 89–99.9 54 55 89.39 78.8–95.3 59 66 > 0.99 − 0.39
7a 9.09 3.4–20.7 5 55 12.12 5.7–23 8 66 > 0.99 0.10
7b 44.44 31.2–58.5 24 54 60.32 47.2–72.2 38 63 > 0.99 0.32
7c 5.56 1.4–16.3 3 54 14.29 7.1–25.9 9 63 > 0.99 0.30
7d 1.85 0.1–11.2 1 54 6.35 2.1–16.3 4 63 > 0.99 0.24
8a 1.82 0.1–11 1 55 10.61 4.7–21.2 7 66 > 0.99 0.39
8b 63.64 49.5–75.9 35 55 75.76 63.4–85.1 50 66 > 0.99 0.26
9a 0.00 0–8.1 0 55 6.15 2–15.8 4 65 > 0.99 0.50
9b 69.09 55–80.5 38 55 90.91 80.6–96.3 60 66 0.37 0.57
9c 12.73 5.7–25.1 7 55 13.64 6.8–24.8 9 66 > 0.99 0.03
10a 52.73 38.9–66.1 29 55 60.61 47.8–72.2 40 66 > 0.99 0.16
10b 1.82 0.1–11 1 55 12.12 5.7–23 8 66 > 0.99 0.44
10c 5.45 1.4–16.1 3 55 3.17 0.6–12 2 63 > 0.99 − 0.11
11a 3.77 0.7–14.1 2 53 10.77 4.8–21.5 7 65 > 0.99 0.28
11b 0.00 0–8.4 0 53 4.69 1.2–14 3 64 > 0.99 0.44
12 1.82 0.1–11 1 55 1.52 0.1–9.3 1 66 > 0.99 − 0.02
13a 94.55 83.9–98.6 52 55 90.77 80.3–96.2 59 65 > 0.99 − 0.15
13b 41.82 28.9–55.9 23 55 48.48 36.1–61 32 66 > 0.99 0.13
13c 18.18 9.5–31.4 10 55 16.67 9–28.3 11 66 > 0.99 − 0.04
14 0.00 0–8.1 0 55 0.00 0–6.9 0 66 > 0.99 0.00
15a 43.64 30.6–57.6 24 55 43.94 31.9–56.7 29 66 > 0.99 0.01
15b 12.73 5.7–25.1 7 55 16.67 9–28.3 11 66 > 0.99 0.11
16 70.37 56.2–81.6 38 54 87.30 76–94 55 63 > 0.99 0.42
17a 12.73 5.7–25.1 7 55 12.12 5.7–23 8 66 > 0.99 − 0.02
17b 1.82 0.1–11 1 55 0.00 0–6.9 0 66 > 0.99 − 0.27
18a 100.00 91.9–100 55 55 100.00 93.1–100 66 66 > 0.99 0.00
18b 18.18 9.5–31.4 10 55 28.79 18.6–41.4 19 66 > 0.99 0.25
18c 3.64 0.6–13.6 2 55 1.52 0.1–9.3 1 66 > 0.99 − 0.14
19 74.55 60.7–84.9 41 55 86.36 75.2–93.2 57 66 > 0.99 0.30
20 43.64 30.6–57.6 24 55 39.39 27.8–52.2 26 66 > 0.99 − 0.09