Skip to main content

Table 2 MPRs and SPRs judgments when commenting on the same sections

From: Librarians and information specialists as methodological peer-reviewers: a case-study of the International Journal of Health Governance

MPR judged a section

N = 368

SPR judged the same section

N = 416

Positive

97

Positive

52 (50%)

  

Negative

5 (5%)

  

Recommended change

15 (15%)

  

No comment

32 (30%)

  

Total

104 (100%)

Negative

39

Negative

6 (12%)

  

Positive

24 (48%)

  

Recommended change

7 (13%)

  

No comment

14 (27%)

  

Total

51 (100%)

Recommended change

59

Recommended change

21 (31%)

  

Positive

19 (28%)

  

Negative

0

  

No comment

28 (41%)

  

Total

68 (100%)

No comment

173

No comment

143 (74%)

  

Positive

24 (12.5%)

  

Negative

1 (0.5%)

  

Recommended change

25 (13%)

  

Total

193 (100%)